Posted May 20, 2007 at 10:08PM by Nicolo S. Listed in: Games, Opinions & Analysis Tags: Sony
Ó

???? - Image 1Given Wii's domination across the charts, one would think that Nintendo is taking the cake this generation. William Usher of CB Games begs to differ, making a list of 10 games that "will murder the Wii". They're saying that Wii is a fad, and won't be able to go toe-to-toe with the Sony PS3 in the near future.

And the 10 games that Usher believes will kill the Nintendo Wii are:

  1. Lair
  2. Warhawk
  3. Heavenly Sword
  4. The Eye of Judgement
  5. Uncharter: Drakes Fortune
  6. Ratchet and Clank: Tools of Destruction
  7. Blacksite: Area 51
  8. John Woo Presents Stranglehold
  9. Turok
  10. Grand Theft Auto IV
It's pretty noticeable how the site always puts the graphics in high regard before taking gameplay into consideration. These may be promising titles, but will they really "murder" the Wii?


[Via CB Games] Permalink  |   Email this  |   Linking Blogs   |   Digg It!

Bookmark / Find this article on:


98 Comments


Sort by:
   by nic (Unregistered) - 2007-05-20
 » !

Its obvious the wii isn't meant to go 'toe to toe with ps3' - that 's just plain dumb to suggest that a console designed for a completely different market and doing really well is supposed to compete with an overpriced dvd player.


   Re: Quixand - 2007-05-20
 » anyone who claims

that the PS3 is overpriced hasn't used one yet.

last i checked the wii is making considerable profit in each unit sold while Sony is actually losing money with every PS3... so please if any product in this discussion is "overpriced" it is definitely not the Playstation 3.

   Re: CHUCKINGROCKSATSPACESHIPS - 2007-05-21
 » Quixand Your Absolutely Right

Wii boys are just uneducated trash talkers. They wish mommy would buy them a PS3.

   Re: Constantinecy (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » ,,

The wii will not be killed by anyone it will die out on its own. Why? Because the people who are interested in it are very limited in comparison with hardcore gamers which go with a ps3 or a 360, and when all people who want a wii,get a wii now that Nintendo is meeting the demand (the only reason for the explosive sales of the wii....stock shortage) the sales will drop down to a minimum (well below of the xbox and ps3) and sustained by children that just got old enough for their mums to by them their first and cheap console at age 10...

   Re: Constantinecy (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » ..

Something to add to my last post.

How long pokemon, Mario and wii sports, can drive a console battle against an xbox and especially a PS3?

   Re: PS3Rider (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » ..

Personally I belive, yes, this will kill off the Wii. The fact plain and simple is that the wii is a fad. As an owner of a Wii I know at first they seem exciting and new, but after you get over the motion they get old and dull. More gamers will swing towards the Wii at first, but when they realise the lack of 'blockbuster' games other than mini-games they will soon swing to either the 360 or PS3. The Wii is more aimed at non-gamers and children in my opinion, and will keep the attention of children longer than gamers, because of its repatition.

   Re: KUYA (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » omg

im a ps3 owner but...
that article is stupid and overkill.
yes we know sony titles at the gamers day are great and all but you dont have to bash the wii because it is irrelevant.

   Re: Devise (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » ...

"Personally I belive, yes, this will kill off the Wii. The fact plain and simple is that the wii is a fad."

It's not a fad it's a fun console. Just not fun enough for pimplely teenagers like yourself. The Wii started with the casual market and is branching out to the hardcore market. The PS3 started with the hardcore market and will branch out to the casual market in 3 to 4 years time when it's affordable to that market.

Nintendo will sell every single Wii it can possibly produce this year. None of these titles are going to stop that.

Anyway for now the PS3 has enough competition from the GBA to keep it busy until some decent software comes out.

   Re: Advertising -


   Re: "Sensible" guy (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » To Quixand

The PS3 is overpriced for a game console. That's the point. The Playstation was always a game console, and they were supposed to be making another with the PS3.
Every overpriced game console before it has failed horribly. Like the NeoGeo and 3DO, the PS3 was double the price of the competition. Sony tried to turn game consoles into high end electronics. That's why they don't sell.

   Re: "Sensible" Shmuck. (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » ur retarded : )

dont compare 3D0 and NEO GEO to PS3, neither of them had Sony backing them.

   Re: nic is a dumb@$$ (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » read above

umm, most blu-ray players sell for about 1000$.
its acutally an inexpensive blu-ray player and game console, not a "dvd player"

   Re: kd (Unregistered) - 2007-05-22
 » where is killzone

hey where is killzone man i think metal gear and killzone will murder both xbox 360 and wii
   by Quixand - 2007-05-20
 » very good games

but it won't "murder" the wii... i've got a PS3 and i believe in these games (although i've only got my sights set on three of them) but it would be foolish to believe that it will kill the wii... but i do hope so, the wii is a piece of crap.


   Re: kniteowl - 2007-05-21
 » I agree

I think that "murdering" the Wii is a bit of an exagerration, but it will make the PS3 start to pick up steam, which is a good thing. I'm waiting for mine with bated breath.
   by 600 bucks for a ps3! (Unregistered) - 2007-05-20
 » For 360 also

# Blacksite: Area 51
# John Woo Presents Stranglehold
# Turok
# Grand Theft Auto IV

You can get these on a better and cheaper system for 200 bucks less


   Re: Quixand - 2007-05-20
 » oh please

Microsoft fails at making their XBox work...

and there isn't even a mention of the XBox in the article!!! 360 Fanboys!!!

   Re: Philip (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » re

and those 200 bucks you lose with 3 year xbox live

   Re: Advertising -


   Re: Hellraiser (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » guess what quixand

Fanboys write these articles! You can tell what kind of fanboy wrote them by whose products they forgot to mention.
Besides, since sony is last place everywhere but Japan, they need to try to do some killing for a change!

XBOX live, $50 year with MS points and headset.
5 million actual members, not 900,000 users making 1.6 million accounts.

A PS3 fanboy is like a broken CD walkman, keeps repeating!

   Re: to hellraiser (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » pwnaaaaaaageeee tahhahha

ps2 was released in 2000
ps3 in late 2006
roughly 7 years of gaming.
7 X the 49.99 you spend per year on Xbox live + $350 + the $400 you paid for the Xbox premium + $750 + 1 stupid hellion fanboy....have a sweet day. : )

   Re: 400 for redlightsofdoom! (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » Sad but true...

Yep, save 200 bucks, so you can buy another when your 360 show you the red lights of doom...
Or...you could buy an "elite" 360...maybe the red lights of doom look better on a black console...
Oh yeah...."elite red lights of doom"
   by nic (Unregistered) - 2007-05-20
 » !

of course it's overpriced - the price is too high! i can buy two x360's for the price of the ps3!! the price is too high considering what use it has - it's just a shiny paper weight without decent games and good selection of blu-ray movies (not lethal weapon etc.!!)


   Re: Quixand - 2007-05-20
 » then go ahead and buy two X360's

if you want...

i just don't get the bitterness you've got there nic... you've gone thru every PS3 article i've read this day and you bash it...

why so bitter man??? is anyone forcing you to get a PS3??? or are you just a little frustrated that it's a little out of your wallet range??? cause there shouldn't be any reason why you're so bitter... unless you want it but can't get it.

   Re: B4H4M00T - 2007-05-20
 » ...

get a job

   Re: pixelsword (Unregistered) - 2007-05-20
 » Yeah, you'll need two 360's...

...when one three lights you can play the other; and about time the other returns back to you, the back-up probably will be three lighting too.

   Re: Folding Junkie! - 2007-05-21
 » nic!

If you upgrade to HDMI you will buy two 360's. You ignorant fanboy! You will have paid more money than a PS3 costs also. $400 plus $480 equals $880 you fool. You haven't posted a useful post yet. What a loser!

   Re: reader (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » @ Quixand

how come you always act like a general for the PS3 anyway? everyone on QJ knows you are obsessed with it, and will defend it to the end, but get over it.

   Re: againnnn (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » agaiiinnnnnnn

ps2 was released in 2000 ps3 in late 2006 roughly 7 years of gaming. 7 X the 49.99 you spend per year on Xbox live + $350 + the $400 you paid for the Xbox premium + $750 + 1 stupid fanboy....have a sweet day. there truly is no argument , anyone who can do basic math can see. stop arguing about price.

   Re: Advertising -


   Re: PSNetwork ID: Divine-God (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » PS3 Owns!

The Xbox 360 can't even compete with the PlayStation 3, the PS3 is a fully functional computer, Blu-Ray player, media center, and more! The 360 just does games, movies, + music... Now Microsoft is doing exactly what Nintendo did with the DS, made a new version because they failed at their older one.
   by bionicclownpoo (Unregistered) - 2007-05-20
 » The Wii is an parasite console

...Most people are getting the Wii because they're waiting for the games to pour out, most noticeably MGS4, Bio Shock, and others to see if the $479.99 Elite and the $599.99 PS3 is worth the purchase. I'm not saying that the Wii won't survive, but after this Christmas, only the Mario games will be worth purchasing, as most Wii games can also go out on the PS2 as well (If you have one)

   by hah (Unregistered) - 2007-05-20
 » hah

That list is stupid, here is the real threat to the Wii:
10) Heavenly Sword
9) Lair
8) Warhawk
7) Gran Turismo 5/HD
6) Tekken 6
5) Afrika
4) Eye of Judgement
3) LittleBigPlanet
2) MGS4
1) FF13/Versus 13
0) God of War 3

Other games of interest are Uncharted, Folklore, Ratchet and Clank, and maybe Killzone. Of course the Wii will not be "Murdered" by the PS3. But these games should close the gap, assuming there is a price cut to go along with them. Nintendo is smart in releasing its biggest games at the end of 2007 when the Wii will be strongest. After that, its all PS3. I'm sitting back watching the fireworks for now. The Wii is tearing up the charts, but can it last? My Wii has been collecting dust since I stopped playing WarioWare and Monkey ball. I just don't see it having a future after 2-3 years but who knows. I'm just a cranky hardcore gamer who sees this generation falling to the casuals. Do they even buy games? What the heck.


   Re: CHUCKINGROCKSATSPACESHIPS - 2007-05-21
 » Don't Forget

Things like HOME Little Big Planet and Fatal Inertia.
   by DH3K_aka_KBobTwo1K (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » haha

I just love how the Xbox fanboys join a convo when there is nothing to do with Xbox. Go away you jelous fu-cking Xbots. Tekken 6 for PS3 is going to be so fun! Once again, fu-ck off Xbots, your console will not last and another is already waiting around the corner. Xbox 360 is a POS. WHY ARE XBOTS ON THE PS3 NEWS? JESUS!


   Re: nllx - 2007-05-21
 » lol little ps3 fanboy

"your console will not last"

Hmm, then why has it been beating the crap ps3 in sales, even during the same time-frame? oh that's right, cause the 360 is actually better than the ps3.

if you say the 360 won't last, then the ps3 is already dead.

SELF PWNT FANBOY!!!

   Re: Meh (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » Yeah fanboys are annoying

Which is why YOU are just as annoying. I suggest you "fu-ck" along with the XBots you talk about because you're just as bad as them.

Idiot.

   Re: nllx - 2007-05-21
 » lol

what did i do to be annoying? tell the truth, state the obvious?

you're the idiot for not looking at the message

   Re: ho (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » hmm

no your an idiot. the ps3 sold more consoles then when your ***** console launched, has free online, blue ray, bluetooth, wifi, cell propheser, sixaxis AND won clsole of the year on IGN. what dose your console have, more games. thats because micosoft figured that even thou they were making a useless console, you fanboys would buy it.

   Re: nllx - 2007-05-21
 » ^you don't know the facts kid

Oh no! PS3 console of they year from IGN?! LOL if you think that's something to be proud of, your just sad.

360 > PS3



don't deny it fanboy ; )

   Re: Meh (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » *Sigh*

"what did i do to be annoying? tell the truth, state the obvious?"

nllx, I was addressing DH3K, not you, which is why I used HIS comments against him.

   Re: Meh (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » Also

"you're the idiot for not looking at the message"

I guess you look at my message again, especially my reference to 'XBots' which should have pointed out who I was talking to! ;)

   Re: Meh (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » This always makes me smile

Ho wrote "no your an idiot".

Oh the irony. ;)
   by nllx - 2007-05-21
 » agree with hah

the games on the article suck. the ones hah posted are definitely better. can't believe even article writers are fanboys who don't really research better games and just spew whatever they want out of their ass.

   by MURDER?? nah ... (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » I think psp can handle that job-

love how the "wii" is surviving- off its past generation games that my friggn phone can emulate- and the "casual" gamers that cant tell the difference between decent grafixs and crapp- " decent" not great- that would be the psp - oh but wait its not the grafixs that matter !!! no its the mind less flick of the wrist wth a remote control...... fun ... - i so remember the 360 getting bashed and now the ps3- wonder where is all the 3rd party support for the "wii" oh - wait .. they all disappeared back in the n64 days - unless ps3 comes around with them damn games the fate may be the same-

   by Quixand (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » What's going on?

?????

It says I'm logged in as user Quixand, but that's not me.

I'll post this to see if it works and then I'll log out if necessary.


   Re: Meh (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » Ok, it's unregistered

So I was not logged in as Quixand afterall, but strange just the same. :|

   Re: Quixand - 2007-05-21
 » meh

it's ok man, happened to me as well a couple of times before..
   by Meh (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » Why is Lair number 1?

It may have seemed impressive a year ago, and the water still looks great today, but to me, the graphics in the game are 'muddy' and unappealing, and I've seen nothing of the gameplay which has impressed me so far in videos.

There are MANY future PS3 games which look better and appear to play better imo, so no way should Lair be at number 1 on that list. :|

   by woods26 (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » console soldiers

sony and ms love to see their little soldiers fight

   by Outsider - 2007-05-21
 » -

Wii will murder itself due to the lack of any real next gen titles. After people get sick of Wiimote and waving in the air with it they will buy Ps3 or X360.

   by Jack (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » I love it.

All you hard core gamers out there that think sony and microsoft made a system for you.... your wrong. Hard core gamers represent a mere fraction of the gaming world. The money lies with the children and casual gamers, not with you. Why do you think the Wii has sold so well, its not because of the hard core gamers.


   Re: kniteowl - 2007-05-21
 » Er yeah...

And that's why all the money for developing games has shifted into developing High definition, Dolby surround sound equipped versions of Bejeweled (or its various clones) and Pokemon.

It just makes good financial sense to cater for casual gamers and children, cos they're where the money lies. PFFFT...

   Re: Thabor (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » Money...


Money for console sales maybe. A year or two from now when the tie ratio for Wii is the same as at launch it won't look like such a great idea.

Hardcore gamers are a valuable audience because they buy games.. Casual gamers, not so much.

   Re: Manny151 (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » To Jack

Yeah but casual gamers don't buy a whole lot of games . They just buy the console on impulse because it's cheap and fun but they wont spend a whole lot of money on games for it especially since it comes with a game already.Once everybody has a Wii but no one is buying games it will die. A slow and sad death.

   Re: bull***** (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » when I bought a wii

they made me buy two games. I picked up zelda and wario wares. Wario wares sucked so I traded it in to get a discounted F.E.A.R. for my PS3. Wii sports and Zelda are the only two games I have enjoyed and 1 is free. I have no plans to buy any other game for the Wii unless it is an exclusive such as Mario Party mainly because the graphics arent that great and I do get tired of swinging the wiimote.
   by dave (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » kill a system

now this artical seems a little more realistic. because at first people where saying "halo will kill ps3" when one game cant really kill any console. but a list of games can. Im just mad that it will take all of these games for ps3 to beat the wii and M$ only needs halo to beat ps3.

but I still think that people will buy what cheaper.

   by Typhon_Inc - 2007-05-21
 » I find it interesting...

That my wii roomate has bought a subscriptions service to rent games, the list he submitted only has one wii game on it. the rest of the list is split 50/50 between 360 and PS3. Does that mean he is becoming a "hardcore gamer"?


   Re: Act II - 2007-05-21
 » it means

hes becoming gay

   Re: comedy - 2007-05-21
 » lol

zing!
   by sam (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » YO!

sorry but no games can make the ps3 "kill" the wii now. I own neither.

   by drew (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » alright

The wii and ps3 target 2 diffrent types of people and when people buy a wii they usally go and buy a diffrent console also , I own a wii and currently thinking of buying a 360. I think all 3 systems are great but I think ps3 is gonna loose because of its price, I know even if i was still working i wouldnt buy one when i can buy other stuff ex: new phone, new tv, new computer, clothes, take a girl somewhere, etc...

   by hush404 - 2007-05-21
 » WHAT?>

Man! you forgot so many awesoem titles! But I'm really surprise Assassin's Creed isn't in there.

Also, I find it oh so funny that the article is focusing on 'The Wii will fall tot eh PS3!! look at the titles!' and they dun even mention teh 360 as a threat, lol.

   by Kutibh (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » umm

What about MGS 4 and LittleBigPlanet???

   by Sammeer Chopra (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » THE PS3 WILLL DIEEEEEEE F_UCK FANBOYS

***** FANBOYS


   Re: lol (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » lol

what wrong microsoft fan boy, too much ps3 to handle lol
   by ShadowSeoul49 (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » Sigh

Got to be kidding me.. None of the three systems are going anywhere. Hell Nintendo has even said they're not competing with the other two companies. Why are people so hellbent on making this into such a war? I don't think anybody here would be dumb enough to refuse a system being given to them. So why even bother bashing one or the other? Just play the games, and stop with brand loyalty. It's getting extremely old, and shows there are too many people around that need to grow the hell up.

   by grapeape (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » ps3 next dreamcast??

"The wii will not be killed by anyone it will die out on its own. Why? Because the people who are interested in it are very limited in comparison with hardcore gamers which go with a ps3 or a 360"

Are you completely stoned? The "hardcore" gamers is a niche at best...maybe 1 of 20 people that play games if your lucky...realistically probably more like 50 to 1. The ps3 has some great games coming out but if you think something like Lair will outsell say Wii Play or Mario Galaxy your out of your mind. I have all 3 consoles and both portables, so I tend to play whats good and dont worry about fanboyish loyalty. I can easily see the ps3 being this generations Dreamcast". Before you bash look at the quality of games that were on the DC and the 3rd parties jumping ship and the "hardcore" gamers going on and on about it...then tell me the parallels arent there. I dont want that to happen, but I really wont be surprised if it does.


   Re: ... (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » ...

Do you actually reply to the guy who said that or talking on your own? What you say is 99%irreleveant to his words... I think you are stoned one here!!!

   Re: wow (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » hmm

the only reason dreamcast died is because it was easy to copy games you didnt even need a modchip, wile in blueray its alot more chalenging so people have to buy the games. ps3 will not die
   by John (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » Surely

Surely hes missed some of the biggest games MGS4, GT4, DMC4, and how can you forget FF13 - which i expect will by itself save the PS3 in Japan.

   by itsblackmelop (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » Damn where is HAZE on this list?

What about the upcoming game HAZE? It's on PSM Mag.
That game should be on the list!


   Re: sup (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » games

what about super rub a dub in 1080P lol!?
   by justincoool (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » Lovin the future of Playstation 3

I think Eight Days looks crazy...and The Getaway...they seem to be under the radar...go to game trailers and check them out!!!!!! Just ordered my PS3 yesterday on amazon......can't wait!


   Re: dave (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » I agree

sonys first party is awsome, and I think that in the future the ps3 will be killing the xbox 1080 and the real nintendo revolution. although by then the ps3 will be the weaker system, it will be just like the ps2 days.

   Re: Lil'Blizz (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » JustinCoool Got My Taste

I'm Looking Forward To Eight Days,The Getaway,GTA:IV,Uncharted
   by ODC (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » Only hardcore

Your' only hardcore if the Virtual Boy is your console of choice. :)

   by i hate you all (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » You are all selectist

you all stupid the wii rocks and your all just scared, remember the internet was supost to be a fad to but it is one of the most amazing things out there, give the wii a chance. and you guys are so stupid cuse i see guys like you in the mail in gamestop and they are so retarted they dont even know what there doing 99% of the time there like: da thia fa !@#$%^& E.c.t e.c.t e.c.t e.c.t and dont say it takes one to know one, cus sorry it wont work. i bet most of you did not even finish high school


   Re: Folding Junkie! - 2007-05-21
 » WOW!!!

That has got to be the most ignorant post ever. It is also completely void of any semblance of proper grammar, punctuation, and correct use of the English language that I have ever seen.

The icing on the cake has to be your statement about most of us not finishing high school. Your post is something that most middle school students would be embarrassed about. Go back to your local Adult Education facility and ask them for some help.

I don't normally rant about grammar and spelling in other posts but you brought this one on yourself. At least try to look like you are actually intelligent yourself when you insult another person/s intelligence level.

Have a miserable day, loser! God knows you must live a miserable life.

   Re: comedy - 2007-05-21
 » erm also

yeah, they said the internet was a fad, it turns out it wasn't....

but then that 'wassup!' buweiser advertising campaign was also a fad... and that died a death...

i would think of other fads which have died out but i can't be bothered.
but you see what i mean right? not all supposed fads turn out to be long lasting hits.
   by Psy (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » ...

...

I have a Wii.

I have a PS3.

I like them both.

All of you suck.

   by spuit (Unregistered) - 2007-05-21
 » LOL!

How the hell did he even forget MGS4?



Add QJ.NET
Add to My Yahoo!
Google Reader Subscribe with Bloglines
Add  to your Kinja digest Subscribe in NewsGator Online
Subscribe with Pluck RSS reader Add 'www.qj.net' to Newsburst from CNET News.com
Subscribe with SearchFox RSS del.icio.us www.qj.net
Add to Technorati Favorite! Add to My AOL
furl! it Stumble for Treehugger!