Posted Jan 19, 2007 at 12:35AM by Rio S. Listed in: Blu-Ray, Off Topic
Ó

This article contains some disturbing images of a (hairy) guy mishandling his Blu ray disk. For the faint of heart, turn away. Kids, don't try this at home.

Somebody over at the IGN Forums has done the unthinkable. He ran steel wool (gasp!) over his Talladega Nights 15 or so times. Then he washed the disk to remove the steel wool fibers, dried it, and played it. Fortunately, it still did. Whew.

We aren't really sure why anyone would scratch steel wool over Resistance: Fall of Man on purpose but this info would be indispensable for those of you who wipe all your stuff with steel wool. This can be proof of how tough the Blu ray disk is, but remember, when trying to destroy something expensive it is always good to be smart than lucky.

Blu Ray Scratch Test - Image 1 Blu Ray Scratch Test - Image 2 the damage - Image 1




[Via IGN Boards] Permalink  |   Email this  |   Linking Blogs   |   Digg It!

Bookmark / Find this article on:


23 Comments


Sort by:
   by Annony - 2007-01-19
 » ...

Okay, maybe Talladega Nights wasn't one of Will Ferrell's better movies, but goddamn...


   Re: Mahalo (Unregistered) - 2007-01-19
 » ugh...

Pretty much every Will Ferrell movie sucks anyway. I hope he picks other WF blu-ray disks to attempt to distroy in the future.

   Re: retards (Unregistered) - 2007-01-19
 » best movie yet

thats his best movie yet bad taste to you guys -2000 points for you
   by ko (Unregistered) - 2007-01-19
 » wow

this prove it... anybody say blu-ray get scratched easily should go to hell. blu-ray is definly got more protection the hd-dvd ever will.


   Re: ILuvGames (Unregistered) - 2007-01-19
 » Stop being argumentative

Both HD-DVD and Blu-ray disks are covered in a scratch resistant coating.

Blu-ray had a reputation for getting scratched easily because the original specification required a cartridge for the disk.

However, with the developement of scratch resistant coatings, Blu-ray nolonger needed a cartridge to protect the disk.

   Re: Vietone - 2007-01-19
 » Not true

HD DVD specification doesnt require the special coating while Blu-ray does.

Alot of HD DVD movies are just as prone to scratches as the regular DVDs because with the thicker space between the the surface and the data, they dont believe its necessary.

Also the special coating would rise the cost of HD DVD to be just as much as Blu-ray.

   Re: ItsameMario (Unregistered) - 2007-01-19
 » ^^^ Ok

So that's a good thing right? It helps keep the cost down for HD-DVD disks and it's no worse than DVDs for scratches.

   Re: abu (Unregistered) - 2007-01-19
 » OH DEAR everything is real eh

You do realize this is NOT a real test from UNBIASED scientists RIGHT?.
   by Advertising -
   by Kite - 2007-01-19
 » Wow.

Everyone posting on those IGN boards look like a titanic dumbass.

   by lmxloco - 2007-01-19
 » Ew

That sink is fudgin NASTY!
Someone needs to take that time used to destroying blu-ray discs to cleaning up his sink.

   by Kristian (Unregistered) - 2007-01-19
 » ...

It may still work... that is true... but I bet the player they are using is less than 6 months old.

I also bet you that if he left that disc in direct sunlight for 3-4 hours and put it directly into a player and then played the movie for 3 times that it would warp enough that it wouldn't play anymore...

   by SeanRoss - 2007-01-19
 » He only did that

Because Talladega Nights was free I bet...

   by Jx1 - 2007-01-19
 » O___o!

DAMN he's hairy.
hahahaha and that indeed is a sick ass sink. : /

   by gtauk - 2007-01-19
 » the sink

i think the sink would look alot cleaner if the steel wool he rubbed off over the sink wasn't there thats probably why it looks so dirty

   by freetechitems (Unregistered) - 2007-01-19
 » FOR SALE

H.COMMUNICATIONS LIMITED
RM B, 9/F, Seapower Industrial Centre,
177 Hoi Bun Road Kwun Tong, Kowloon Hong Kong
Date established 1990
Legal Form Limited Liability Company
Co.Registration No.: 281566


(H.COMMUNICATIONS LIMITED ) well known in the area of TELECOMMUNICATION.we sell whole sale and retailer prices of the stated products.we are based in HONG KONG.

MOBILE PHONES,LAPTOPS,PLASMA TV,GAMES E.G IPOD,XBOXS,PLAYSTATION,SIDEKICKS,IMATES JASJAM,PALM TREOS,QTECK,NINTENDO WII,DEGITAL CAMERALS.LGS,E.T.C

WE stock as much posible products you are willing to buy.here we displayed some of our price list.

(NOKIA PHONES)

Nokia N95...........$400
NOKIA N GAGE.........$120USD
NOKIA 9500.........(communication) us$120
Brand new Nokia n71 **** 140usd
Brand new Nokia n92 **** 150usd
Brand new Nokia n93 **** 190usd
Brand new Nokia 6280 **** 140 USD
Brand new Nokia 6270 **** 140 USD
Brand new Nokia 6111 **** 150 USD
Brand new Nokia 6060 **** 105 USD
Brand new Nokia N91**** 155 USD
Brand new Nokia N90 **** 170 USD
Brand new Nokia N70 ****160 USD
Brand new Nokia 1600 **** 100 USD



O2 3G Datacard $120usd
Orange Blackberry $110usd
Orange 3GDatacard $110usd
Orange SPVC500 $110usd
Orange SPV M2000 $114usd

(PANASONIC)

Panasonic X60 $120usd
Panasonic X60 $120usd
Panasonic X70 $124usd
Panasonic X300 $114usd
Panasonic X700 $132usd

(SONY ERICSSON)

Sony ericsson T616 850/1900 --US$125
SONY ERICSSON R520m(UNLOCK)-- US$89
SONY CMD-Z5-- US$89
SONY ERICSSON R380 World-- US$89
SONY ERICSSON R380s-- US$69
SONY ERICSSON T68m-- ---US$79
SONY ERICSSON T610--------- US$109
SONY CMD-MZ5-- ---------------US$109
SONY ERICSSON P800(UNLOCK)-- US$105
SONY ERICSSON P900(UNLOCK)---US$108
SONY ERICSSON P980i(UNLOCK)---US$115

NEXTEL I860 AT JUST $100
NEXTEL I930 AT JUST $130

(PLAYSTATION)

Play Station 2 ...........$110usd
Play Station 3 ...........$500usd
NINTENDO WII ...............$100USD


(samsung)

Brand new Samsung D600 140 USD
Brand new Samsung D500 130 USD
Brand new SamsungP860 130 USD
Brand new Samsung P850 145 USD
Brand new Samsung E730 130 USD
Brand new Samsung D550 **** 130 USD
Brand new Samsung D510 **** 135 USD
Brand new Samsung E850 **** 120 USD
Brand new Samsung D710 **** 135 USD

(Motorola)

Brand new Motorola A910 **** 150 USD
Brand new Motorola A728 **** 140 USD
Brand new Motorola A732 **** 135 USD
Brand new Motorola Q **** 120 USD
Brand new Motorola E895 **** 120 USD
Brand new Motorola V3x **** 130 USD
Brand new Motorola V8 **** 120 USD
Brand new Motorola V6 **** 120 USD
Brand new Motorola A1010 **** 100 USD
Brand new Motorola E1060 **** 90 USD
Brand new Motorola V1050 **** 90 USD
Motorola Motorola a388c....... 150usd


(IMATE JASJAR PHONES)

I-MATE Smartflip ....... $140
I-MATE JAMin ......... $240
I-MATE JASJAm ........ $280
I-MATE K-JAM ......... $180
I-MATE SP5 ......... $150
I-MATE SP5m ......... $155
I-MATE SP4m ......... $120
I-MATE JAM Black ........ $150
I-MATE JAM ......... $160
I-MATE PDA2 ......... $190
I-MATE PDA2k ......... $168
I-MATE SP3i ......... $130
I-MATE SP3 ......... $135
I-MATE Pocket PC ......... $140
I-MATE Smartphone2 ........ $110
I-MATE Smartphone ........ $115


(LAPTOPS)

LAPTOPS:
IBM Thinkpad T42 1.7GHz 512MB 40GB CD-RW/DVD 15" XGA ;;$400
IBM ThinkPad X41 Tablet PC 1.5GHz 1.5GB 60GB Bluetooth;;;$500
IBM Thinkpad T43 1.86GHz 2GB 60GB DVD Burner 14.1" SXG
SONY VAIO A217S-- 100GB-- 512MB RAM-- XPHOME-------------$500
SONY VAIO B1VP-- 40GB HD-- 512MB RAM-- XP PRO--------------$430
SONY VAIO T370P/L-- 60GB HD-- 512MB RAM-- XP----------------$400
SONY VAIO A215Z 60GB HD-- 512MB RAM-- XP------------


   Re: Mr. Common Sense (Unregistered) - 2007-01-20
 » advertise deez

Get that sh*t off here, fu*khead.
   by DH3K_aka_KBobTwo1K - 2007-01-19
 » AREN'T REALLY SURE!?!

Its called a "test", look it up.

   by Advertising -
   by damonous - 2007-01-19
 » HD-DVD discs skip on a spec of dust

I own both an HD-DVD player (Toshiba's latest, HD-A2, mass-market machine) and a Blu-Ray (PS3). While I'm not looking to prove the "steel wool theory" for myself (even though Talledega Nights so rightly deserves it), I CAN tell you that HD-DVD is certainly very susceptible to the slightest blip on the surface. Recently, I bought Chronicles of Rid*****. The disc had come off from the case-spindle in transit. I played it until the scene where Rid***** goes to New Mecca. Then, suddenly, MASSIVE skipping and MPEG blocking and distortion, to the point where it finally froze. I had to pop it out. Luckily, I was able to polish off the light scratch with a cloth, and that corrected the problem. However, if the "steel wool test" is not a hoax, this means that BluRay has FAR BETTER error correction handling. Whether or not the HD-DVD disc had hard coat (allowing me to clear off the scratch) is somewhat immaterial, considering that it would have been TOAST had I not been able to clear the scratch, because the player certainly had no way of correcting for it.


   Re: Mr. Common Sense (Unregistered) - 2007-01-20
 » you can't help blu ray with lies

Since you say it skips on a spec of dust yet you later say you have to polish out a light scratch, I'd say you are full of sh*t. Only a wealthy dumb ass buys both blu ray and HD-DVD players anyway.
   by Gerge (Unregistered) - 2007-01-19
 » OH NO NOT AGAIN

Here we go again I OWN BOTH THE HD_DVD and yes properly a 360 BUT ETC ETC ETC and guess which machine he wants to slag off ????,why do you even bother ????. Go tell it to the film buffs because gamers have already chosen their format.

   by pedro_maxfat (Unregistered) - 2007-01-19
 » nasty

Maby the blu-ray does work but if the cd falls on the sink IT WILL NOT WORK because its so nasty the hair in it will destroy the cd
LOL

   by Shatterdome - 2007-01-19
 » Pretty good...

But he made the scratches in the direction that doesn't bother the laser as much. He should have ran the wool around the disc in a circular motion, that disrupts the laser alot more.....still impressive if it works with absolutely no hiccups...

   by Devise (Unregistered) - 2007-01-20
 » ...

Would be interesting to know if the whole movie still played, we really on see 5 seconds of it. I've never had problems with scratched disc myself except for when hiring games or movies from a video store. I usually ask them to buff the disc if it looks bad.

I know one thing, the Blu-Ray pirates are still going to say they need to backup the discs in case they get scratched.

I wonder if HD DVD will ever take note and add the extra protective layer (if not already present) to their discs. It's not like it would be very hard for them to add.



Add QJ.NET
Add to My Yahoo!
Google Reader Subscribe with Bloglines
Add  to your Kinja digest Subscribe in NewsGator Online
Subscribe with Pluck RSS reader Add 'www.qj.net' to Newsburst from CNET News.com
Subscribe with SearchFox RSS del.icio.us www.qj.net
Add to Technorati Favorite! Add to My AOL
furl! it Stumble for Treehugger!